Christchurch教堂在争议中革新

发表于2013-04-10    718人浏览    5人跟帖    总热度:159  

  • 文件格式:ZIP
  • 文件大小:11.72KB

Christchurch Cathedral: issues in historical renovation

位置:新西兰 克赖斯特彻奇

分类:文化建筑

内容:实景照片

图片:13张

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第1张图片

设计方:大教堂重建项目组
图片来源:Andrew Collins, Cathedral Conversations, Playback Theatre

该重建计划向大家阐述了一个问题:各个时代的不同建筑师,当面对重建一座已存在多年的建筑物时,应该如何处理遇到的各种问题。通常来说,一个项目的实施受到时间、预算或者客户的需求等的影响,但是假设这些问题影响都不大,是否就算是到了最佳的时机,可以重建历史建筑,以适应当代当地的风土人情?而现在,这些问题对于震后被毁坏的克赖斯特彻奇大教堂来说则是不容忽视的。一种全新的外观可以在保留建筑物的遗迹同时将城市与人联系起来;而另一方面,若是完全依照教堂原样重建,则可以保留市民原先的精神殿堂,而且在这座不断发展变化的城市里,它会变成具有历史意义的瑰宝。该项目在设立之初就树立了这样的理念——大教堂的重建工作必须强调“为古朴的视觉赋予新意”,同时运用新西兰的独特材料强调文化上的尺度感与光感。在过去的18个月里,教会的主教、教堂财产委托人以及教堂重建项目组为这座教堂设想了很多方案。他们不得不考虑各方面的因素来决定它未来的样子。迄今为止他们总结出了三种不同的选择,而且他们将会公开面向社会征求意见。项目组将会分别在四月10日、16日和24日在奥克兰和克赖斯特彻奇举办公众论坛,各种意见将会在不同程度上讨论如何保留这座建筑的记忆,同时也需要大家考虑这个问题:当我们改造一座建筑的时候,我们可以,或者说是我们能被允许背离我们的历史多远呢?

The renovation project illustrates a problem that is facing many architects in a day and age when faced with the question of what to do with an existing building. Often, the time constraint, budget, or client's desires may suggest the direction a project will take, but when none of these issues are present, is it best to restore the historical structure, renew it in a similar vernacular, or completely redefine it into the contemporary era? This is exactly the issue around the earthquake-devastated cathedral in Christchurch. A new look would suggest continuity with the city and its people while retaining vestiges of the original memory of the building. On the other hand, a cut-and-dry restoration would fully retain the nature of the spiritual and civic building of worship that would ultimately remain a historic gem in a growing city. What has been set from the beginning is that the cathedral's renovation should embody a 'renewed ancient vision', and should revisit a sense of scale and quality of light while referencing New Zealand’s culture in the massing and materials. Over the past 18 months, the Anglican diocese of Christchurch, the church property trustees, and the cathedral project group have taken several considerations into account when deciding the future of the spiritual house of worship. They acknowledged many factors, from the practical structural integrity of the existing construction, to its heritage legacy, to the church's actual mission within the community. So far they have refined three different options, as highlighted previously, and are now asking the community for their input. Three public forums will be held on April 10th, 16th, and 24th in Auckland and Christchurch all proposals retain the memory of the building to varying degrees; it's the appropriateness of each scheme that is in question. How far can we - and should we - stray from history before losing the very nature of place?

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第2张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-2

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第3张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-3

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第4张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-4

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第5张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-5

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第6张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-6

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第7张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-7

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第8张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-8

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第9张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-9

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第10张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-10

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第11张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-11

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第12张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-12

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新第13张图片

Christchurch教堂在争议中革新-13

分享至

分享到微信朋友圈 ×

打开微信"扫一扫",扫描上方二维码
请点击右上角按钮 ,选择 

 发表于2015-01-13   |  只看该作者      

2

不错的资料,值得学习和收藏!

 发表于2015-04-22   |  只看该作者      

3

很棒!我也要想做出这种感觉!

 发表于2015-04-23   |  只看该作者      

4

立面很有特点,功能性也不错,值得收藏

 发表于2015-05-03   |  只看该作者      

5

以说很难找到像这样子大尺度、大规模的,这么高速度的发展,同样的平行

 发表于2015-05-04   |  只看该作者      

6

该帖未通过审核,已被删除

 回帖后跳转到最后一页


猜你爱看

分享